GRMrGecko/midi-harbor
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull requests Projects Releases Packages Wiki Activity Actions
midi-harbor/specs
History
James Coleman 57fe7ff53a fix(service): wait for launchd to drop the old job before loading the new 
- Update now stopped the daemon and failed with "Bootstrap failed: 5: Input/output error" on macOS, leaving the agent's plist written and no job loaded. `launchctl bootout` returns once the daemon has been sent SIGTERM, and launchd refuses `bootstrap` until the daemon has exited and the job has left the domain.
- Installing or replacing the launchd agent now waits for the booted-out job to leave, for up to 25 seconds, which covers the 20 seconds launchd allows before SIGKILL.
- Starting the service now loads the agent's plist first when launchd does not hold the job, so the window's Start button and `service start` recover a registration left unloaded instead of failing in `kickstart`.
- The stand-in launchctl in the service lifecycle test returns from `bootout` while the daemon is still stopping and refuses `bootstrap` until it has gone, as launchd does, so `service install --start` over a running daemon pins the regression.
2026-10-04 08:43:28 -05:00
..
001-service-and-clients docs(specs): drop the spec names used before the renumbering 2026-09-29 14:35:33 -05:00
002-configuration First commit 2026-09-28 13:59:10 -05:00
003-virtual-ports First commit 2026-09-28 13:59:10 -05:00
004-hardware-devices First commit 2026-09-28 13:59:10 -05:00
005-network-ports feat(network): follow a machine's session and forget removed ones 2026-10-02 11:56:20 -05:00
006-bluetooth-midi First commit 2026-09-28 13:59:10 -05:00
007-routing First commit 2026-09-28 13:59:10 -05:00
008-resilience First commit 2026-09-28 13:59:10 -05:00
009-observability First commit 2026-09-28 13:59:10 -05:00
010-graphical-interface build(gui): update libcosmic to master 03d7dcb832bc 2026-09-29 14:35:56 -05:00
011-midi-service-crash-warning First commit 2026-09-28 13:59:10 -05:00
012-test-note First commit 2026-09-28 13:59:10 -05:00
013-windows-support docs(specs): drop the spec names used before the renumbering 2026-09-29 14:35:33 -05:00
014-mac-app-store-mode docs(specs): drop the spec names used before the renumbering 2026-09-29 14:35:33 -05:00
015-mac-menus First commit 2026-09-28 13:59:10 -05:00
016-app-store-submission fix(appstore): drop winit's private blur call that App Review refused 2026-10-03 09:39:12 -05:00
017-appimage fix(appimage): tell running desktops when the icon is installed 2026-10-02 12:59:23 -05:00
018-remembered-machines feat(network): follow a machine's session and forget removed ones 2026-10-02 11:56:20 -05:00
019-daemon-updates fix(service): wait for launchd to drop the old job before loading the new 2026-10-04 08:43:28 -05:00
README.md fix(appstore): drop winit's private blur call that App Review refused 2026-10-03 09:39:12 -05:00

README.md

Specifications

One spec per capability, numbered by topic. Each holds its user stories, requirements, success criteria, research and tasks; the architecture, the daemon contract and the command-line contract are in 001, and every spec follows the constitution.

Requirement (FR), success criterion (SC), research (R) and task (T) numbers are unique across every spec, and the code cites them by number. They were given in the order the work was done, so one spec's numbers are not contiguous; the lists below say which spec holds each. The one exception is 014, whose task list started again at T001: its T001 to T034 are cited as 014's.

Spec What it covers
001-service-and-clients The single executable, the daemon, the gRPC contract, the command line, installing the service, packaging; the architecture and the original input
002-configuration The configuration file, applying changes while running, export and import, Apple's setup, capabilities
003-virtual-ports Ports applications on one computer use to talk to each other
004-hardware-devices Attached MIDI hardware and other applications' ports, hot-plug, identity
005-network-ports RTP-MIDI between computers: discovery, invitations, the journal, machines, the automatic port
006-bluetooth-midi Bluetooth LE MIDI, connecting out and advertising
007-routing Routes between any two endpoints, loops, system-exclusive, the repeater
008-resilience Recovery: backoff, sleep and wake, releasing notes, restoring state, the MIDI service dying
009-observability State, counters, history, the monitor, the diagnostic report
010-graphical-interface The libcosmic window and its redesign
011-midi-service-crash-warning Warning that other apps may have lost MIDI; when traffic last moved each way
012-test-note Sending a note out of an endpoint to test what listens
013-windows-support Windows as a first-class platform
014-mac-app-store-mode The sandboxed App Store build, run from the menu bar
015-mac-menus The menus on macOS: File, Edit, View, Window and Help
016-app-store-submission Building the package App Store Connect takes
017-appimage The AppImage for Linux, and registering the daemon from it
018-remembered-machines Machines a network port connected to: forgetting old connections, following a session that moved, proving which port a session is; answering Apple over a link-local address
019-daemon-updates Telling that the daemon is another build than the window, and updating it when asked

Where each number is

001-service-and-clients

  • Requirements: FR-036–FR-039, FR-039a, FR-039b, FR-039c, FR-039d, FR-039e, FR-039f, FR-039g, FR-039h, FR-040–FR-043
  • Success criteria: SC-010, SC-014, SC-014a, SC-014b, SC-014c, SC-016
  • Research: R-003, R-007–R-009, R-012, R-023, R-028, R-042, R-052–R-054, R-059, R-081
  • Tasks: T001–T006, T009–T016, T028–T035, T038–T039, T041–T060, T063, T146–T147, T151–T154, T157, T166–T167, T172, T241

002-configuration

  • Requirements: FR-049–FR-053
  • Success criteria: SC-015
  • Research: R-011, R-043, R-061
  • Tasks: T022–T026, T040, T061–T062, T149–T150, T173–T174

003-virtual-ports

  • Requirements: FR-001–FR-002, FR-002a, FR-003–FR-007
  • Success criteria: SC-001, SC-002, SC-008
  • Research: R-002, R-014, R-048
  • Tasks: T064–T070, T072–T076, T161, T182, T197

004-hardware-devices

  • Requirements: FR-015a, FR-015b, FR-015c, FR-015d, FR-015e, FR-015f, FR-015g
  • Success criteria: SC-010a, SC-010c
  • Research: R-013, R-024, R-027, R-038–R-040, R-047, R-055
  • Tasks: T104, T107–T111, T116, T119, T158, T188, T190, T193

005-network-ports

  • Requirements: FR-008–FR-015, FR-015h, FR-015i
  • Success criteria: SC-003, SC-006, SC-009, SC-011
  • Research: R-004, R-005, R-015–R-016, R-017–R-018, R-020–R-022, R-036–R-037, R-046, R-049, R-056–R-057, R-060, R-063, R-065–R-066, R-068, R-071, R-073, R-076, R-080, R-082
  • Tasks: T007, T077–T082, T082a, T083–T096, T100–T103, T159, T168, T176, T179, T181, T184–T187, T191, T196, T198–T200

006-bluetooth-midi

  • Requirements: FR-016–FR-021
  • Research: R-006, R-041, R-058, R-064, R-075, R-077
  • Tasks: T008, T037, T128–T137, T156, T162, T169–T171, T175

007-routing

  • Requirements: FR-030, FR-030a, FR-030b, FR-031–FR-034, FR-034a, FR-035
  • Success criteria: SC-010b
  • Research: R-019, R-029–R-030, R-032, R-062
  • Tasks: T105–T106, T111a, T112–T115, T117–T118, T160, T177, T183

008-resilience

  • Requirements: FR-022–FR-029
  • Success criteria: SC-004, SC-005, SC-007
  • Research: R-010, R-031, R-033–R-035, R-044–R-045, R-050–R-051, R-067, R-069–R-070, R-072, R-074, R-079
  • Tasks: T017–T020, T020a, T021, T036, T071, T071a, T097–T099, T127, T148, T155, T192, T195

009-observability

  • Requirements: FR-044–FR-048
  • Success criteria: SC-012, SC-013
  • Tasks: T027, T120–T126, T163–T165, T178, T194

010-graphical-interface

  • Research: R-001, R-025–R-026, R-078
  • Tasks: T138–T145, T180, T189, T240

011-midi-service-crash-warning

  • Requirements: FR-M01, FR-M02, FR-M03, FR-M04
  • Success criteria: SC-M01, SC-M02
  • Research: R-101
  • Tasks: T236–T238, T242–T243

012-test-note

  • Requirements: FR-N01, FR-N02
  • Success criteria: SC-N01
  • Tasks: T239

013-windows-support

  • Requirements: FR-W01, FR-W02, FR-W03, FR-W04, FR-W05, FR-W06, FR-W07, FR-W08, FR-W09, FR-W10, FR-W11, FR-W12
  • Success criteria: SC-W01, SC-W02, SC-W03
  • Research: R-083–R-093
  • Tasks: T201–T226, T227–T228, T229–T230, T231–T235

014-mac-app-store-mode

  • Requirements: FR-A01, FR-A02, FR-A03, FR-A04, FR-A05, FR-A06, FR-A07, FR-A08, FR-A09, FR-A10, FR-A11, FR-A12, FR-A13, FR-A14
  • Success criteria: SC-A01, SC-A02, SC-A03, SC-A04, SC-A05
  • Research: R-094–R-100
  • Tasks: T001–T034

015-mac-menus

  • Requirements: FR-U01, FR-U02, FR-U03
  • Success criteria: SC-U01
  • Research: R-102
  • Tasks: T244

016-app-store-submission

  • Requirements: FR-S01, FR-S02, FR-S03
  • Success criteria: SC-S01
  • Research: R-103, R-110
  • Tasks: T245, T255

017-appimage

  • Requirements: FR-I01, FR-I02, FR-I03, FR-I04, FR-I05
  • Success criteria: SC-I01
  • Research: R-104, R-109
  • Tasks: T246–T248, T254

018-remembered-machines

  • Requirements: FR-P01, FR-P02, FR-P03, FR-P04, FR-P05, FR-P06, FR-P07
  • Success criteria: SC-P01, SC-P02
  • Research: R-105–R-107
  • Tasks: T249–T252

019-daemon-updates

  • Requirements: FR-B01, FR-B02, FR-B03, FR-B04, FR-B05, FR-B06, FR-B07
  • Success criteria: SC-B01, SC-B02
  • Research: R-108
  • Tasks: T253